Rings and RSVP
Live
Money

Selena Gomez's wedding cake mishap with Only Murders cast

Selena Gomez recalls Martin Short cutting into her wedding cake with Benny Blanco before the couple could, a moment she cherishes from their September 2025 London wedding.

Selena Gomez recalls Martin Short cutting into her wedding cake with Benny Blanco before the couple could, a moment she...

Selena Gomez married music producer Benny Blanco in September 2025. During their London wedding reception, castmate Martin Short from Only Murders in the Building accidentally cut into their wedding cake before they could.

The incident became a shared memory for the close friends. Gomez appeared with Short on Jimmy Kimmel Live! On November 19 to recount the story. She said she was too distracted by being newly married to care about the cake at the time.

Cast reactions and friendship

Martin Short admitted to possibly having had a drink before the cake incident. He cut the cake while his co-star Steve Martin was leaving the party. Short described the cake as 'small', though the wedding had more than ten guests.

Gomez was grateful Short tried to fix the cake. She said she will never forget the memory. The singer and actress described Short as looking like 'a little dog with his tail between his legs' afterwards. She stated she was 'okay with it' and that it's now a memory they share. Gomez and Short are described as super close, true friends.

Benny Blanco later joked on the Today show that the cake had to be put back together after Short ate part of it. The first slice went to the cast members instead of the newlyweds. Gomez reflected on her original wish. "I thought it would be 'very sweet to have just a small 'Just Married' cake," she said.

Wedding reception and guest experience

The London wedding reception featured a major tented setup. It accommodated 18 to 20 musicians and included a dance floor and a nightclub for the after-party. The venue was arranged with sections containing couches and chairs, each housing 15 people. One of these sections contained the wedding cake.

Other celebrities attended, including Taylor Swift, who gave a speech. The layout was designed for an intimate yet celebratory guest experience amidst a larger party atmosphere.

Interview reflections and future projects

The cake story was a highlight of the Jimmy Kimmel Live! Interview. Martin Short defended his actions during the segment. "First of all, it's insane because I am blameless in the story," he said.

Gomez appreciated his attempt at repair. She noted, I love the teeth marks of the fork where he tried to save it, really nicely done.

The friends will reunite on screen. Gomez and Short will appear together in the sixth season of Hulu's Only Murders in the Building, which returns on December 8. The new season is rebranded as Only Murders in London.

Topics

#Money

Related coverage

More from Money